Search

Fashion

Paul Anthony Kelly's Style Evolution: From Prep to Provocative

Tan FranceTan FranceSep 24, 2026
Discover the dramatic sartorial transformation of Paul Anthony Kelly, as he sheds his preppy image for a bold, darker aesthetic, influenced by his latest role in 'American Horror Story'. This article delves into his evolving fashion choices, highlighting key moments and designer collaborations that define his new style direction.

Embracing the Dark Side: Kelly's Provocative Premiere Look

A Striking Departure from Classic Prep

Paul Anthony Kelly, an actor celebrated for his previous preppy fashion sensibilities, surprised many at the premiere of "American Horror Story: 13" in New York. Abandoning his signature clean-cut style, Kelly stepped onto the red carpet in an ensemble that was both edgy and sophisticated, signaling a dramatic shift in his public image.

The All-Black Hermès Statement

Styled by Warren Alfie Baker, Kelly's outfit was a masterclass in understated rebellion. He sported an entirely black Hermès look, featuring a tailored single-breasted jacket, a matching shirt, and a tie. However, the true showstopper was a pair of impeccably fitted black leather pants, which lent a daring and unconventional edge to the traditional suiting. Completing the look, Jacques Marie Mage sunglasses added a touch of mystery, while a Vacheron Constantin watch with a unique teal-blue crocodile strap offered the only splash of color, drawing attention to his refined accessories.

Leather's Rising Prominence in Menswear

Kelly's choice of leather trousers reflects a growing trend in men's fashion, where influential figures like Alexander Skarsgård and Pedro Pascal have also opted for leather over conventional tailoring. This sartorial move injects a subversive element into menswear, allowing for bolder expressions of personal style. Kelly's transformation is particularly notable, moving away from the polished look reminiscent of his portrayal of John F. Kennedy Jr. in "Love Story."

From Kennedy Prep to 'American Horror Story' Chic

Throughout the past year, Kelly's wardrobe has largely echoed the sophisticated yet relaxed style of JFK Jr., characterized by Ralph Lauren blazers, checked bomber jackets, crisp Chanel shirts, and elegant loafers. His red carpet appearances often featured designs from Giuliva Heritage and Dior, embodying a classic, patrician charm. However, his recent Hermès ensemble clearly demonstrates his evolution beyond the "Love Story" aesthetic, embracing a more adventurous and darker fashion narrative as he delves into new acting roles.

A New Chapter: Kelly's Role in 'American Horror Story: 13'

This upcoming season marks a significant milestone for Kelly, representing his first major role since his acclaimed performance as JFK Jr. in "Love Story." He joins a stellar cast for Ryan Murphy's highly anticipated "American Horror Story," alongside talents such as Alex Consani, Avantika, and Madelaine Petsch, in addition to many familiar faces from the anthology. The darker mood of his new co-stars, like Angela Bassett's Falguni Shane Peacock gown and Sarah Paulson's Valentino dress with a tulle-and-mesh bodice, perfectly complements Kelly's new stylistic direction. While the specifics of his role remain under wraps, his fashion evolution suggests a journey into a more complex and darker character, signifying a bold new phase in his caree

Continue Reading

Related Articles